README.txt
- consider a readme.html with links?
I personally like a little text file at least telling me what is up with
the release, that I can open with emacs or textpad or whatever. I think
the readme should just be a few quick notes, things that are new in the
release, what it's about, what's changed ect. and then it should point to
where the real installation notes are. Perhaps we should rename
README.txt to RELEASE_NOTES.txt
- need installation quick start here
Yes, would be good to have that in a text file at the top level. And
perhaps as html as well, in the real user docs.
doc/user/*.html
- we will need up date these files
- looks like the place for a user's guide with screen snapshots
Yes. I think it might be nice to keep around the how to with the files
for a bit though.
startup.bat- I would like the zip and and run startup.bat
- (GEOSERVER_HOME is a bad idea bin/startup.bat could figure this out)
- startup does not, it keeps control of the shell when called from the
command line
- requirement to run from GEOSERVER_HOME & set the variable is a bit much
- cannot call startup.bat from explorer (and never will be able to given
above restriction
- need a pretty shortcut/icon
- 8081 is not the "usual" port - try for port 80 in a release
I think my ideal would be something like an install shield, which would
set the variables, and during install would allow the user to choose an
alternate port. The problem with 80 is that it won't work if people are
running a normal webserver.
Build/War (from Windows Perspective)
- Why do I have to download ant?
- And build the war?
- Isn't a war supposed to be included in the distribution? (we could
skip the ant requirement then)
We should move to ant not being required for sure. That wasn't really
possibly before the web config tool. War file in the distribution could
be the way to go.
- unit tests are annoying before building war (although could be
reassuring I suppose)
Yes that is annoying. Perhaps we should turn them off.
- we need to move the external directory stuff up to the top for our
users to edit
You mean in the build.xml file? That's a good idea.
conf
- some extra datastores seem to have been added
- refractions hydra is used as example 
Yes, I'd say we should go back to the one I used for 1.1.0 - it gives
samples for all four supported datastores.
Internal TOmcat - test-clean:
- only copies the servlets over
Yes, I don't think anyone's done any work on getting it working. I'd put
this as essential for the beta release. As an extension to the 'why do I
need ant?' there is also 'why do I need a servlet container', and the
answer to that should be 'you don't, just use the built in one'. And they
should be able to start it right up, at least with a bat file.
Ok, that's all from me for now. I have to set up new computer and
environments, but early next week I'll probably send an email similar to
Jody's, with every little thing I want to see done for 1.2beta and 1.2.0
(which I'm really excited about, this new stuff is taking GeoServer to a
whole new level, great work guys).
Chris