[Geoserver-devel] svn commit access

I created my Xircles account two weeks ago and applied to join the
GeoServer and GeoTools projects, but my credentials are still being
refused when I try to svn commit. Xircles still lists my application as
pending, but my Jira account is alive.

Who are the "project despots" for these, and how long should it take to
get commit access?

Who are the svn admins who can diagnose technical problems with access
to the repositories?

--
Ben Caradoc-Davies <Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com>
Software Engineer
CSIRO Exploration and Mining
26 Dick Perry Avenue, Kensington WA 6151, Australia

Hi Ben,

Usually how it works to get commit access you need to submit a number of patches first. Once your work has gained the trust of one of the current committers they can nominate you.

Until then, you should be able to check out the code from svn, generate diffs for patches, without having authentication to commit.

Our setup on Xircles is a bit odd at the moment. Currently its an all or nothing setup, where if you join the project you are given full blown commit access. I have been meaning to set this up so that you can join the project as just a user, but have yet to get around to it.

-Justin

Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com wrote:

I created my Xircles account two weeks ago and applied to join the
GeoServer and GeoTools projects, but my credentials are still being
refused when I try to svn commit. Xircles still lists my application as
pending, but my Jira account is alive.

Who are the "project despots" for these, and how long should it take to
get commit access?

Who are the svn admins who can diagnose technical problems with access
to the repositories?

--
Justin Deoliveira
The Open Planning Project
jdeolive@anonymised.com

Hi Ben; this is the first I have heard of you on the geotools-devel list :slight_smile: Oh wait I see my email rule moved your introduction email off to my geoserver folder ...
I see Rob introduced you a while ago; have you managed to read the developers guid and so forth? It should take a couple of minuets if we know who you are and what you are about; but we honestly don't even open up that admin screen unless we have a bit of an email exchange - I was expecting Rob to nominate you for svn access when he had brought you up to speed ...

admin@anonymised.com will get you in contact with a couple of people managing the svn repostiory for GeoTools; the process here is either:
- email from a module maintainer saying they have reviewed your patches and would like you to have access
- an email request from you about an unsuported you would like to work on yourself

But first a question - have you read the developers guide and did you have any questions about how we operate.

Cheers,
Jody

Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com wrote:

I created my Xircles account two weeks ago and applied to join the
GeoServer and GeoTools projects, but my credentials are still being
refused when I try to svn commit. Xircles still lists my application as
pending, but my Jira account is alive.

Who are the "project despots" for these, and how long should it take to
get commit access?

Who are the svn admins who can diagnose technical problems with access
to the repositories?

Hi Ben,

Justin is correct about procedure but you may be using Rob A. to vet
your work and he may be asking you to commit directly to svn on his
say-so. I believe he nominated you which should satisfy Justin.

You do know that svn and wiki are different accounts, right? The former
goes through admin@anonymised.com dotnet.

Ideally you would be willing to grab the OSGeo copyright assignment
agreement off the wiki and sign your copyright over to OSGeo (for all
the good reasons explained on the page). Oh, and make Rob sign it too,
all to show you are more hip than he these days. All that info is in the
developer guide which you should read to get a sense of what's in there
for when you need it.

For the xicles stuff, the process is ever changing and complex so Jody
seems to be the one who really understands it. I did notice codehaus go
down for a server upgrade this weekend and it's been rock solid for me
since then---let's hope that lasts.

--adrian

On Sun, 2008-02-10 at 22:34 -0500, Justin Deoliveira wrote:

Hi Ben,

Usually how it works to get commit access you need to submit a number of
patches first. Once your work has gained the trust of one of the current
committers they can nominate you.

Until then, you should be able to check out the code from svn, generate
diffs for patches, without having authentication to commit.

Our setup on Xircles is a bit odd at the moment. Currently its an all or
nothing setup, where if you join the project you are given full blown
commit access. I have been meaning to set this up so that you can join
the project as just a user, but have yet to get around to it.

-Justin

Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com wrote:
> I created my Xircles account two weeks ago and applied to join the
> GeoServer and GeoTools projects, but my credentials are still being
> refused when I try to svn commit. Xircles still lists my application as
> pending, but my Jira account is alive.
>
> Who are the "project despots" for these, and how long should it take to
> get commit access?
>
> Who are the svn admins who can diagnose technical problems with access
> to the repositories?
>

Thanks, Adrian.

Do I need both a TOPP agreement for GeoServer and an OSGeo for GeoTools?

I did not know that svn is a separate account. Should I email
admin@anonymised.com dotnet, or wait until my paperwork is processed?

I will be indeed working closely with Rob A, mainly on getting community
schemas up and going on the GeoServer 1.6 / GeoTools 2.4 branches. I
will be working in community/unsupported, and I do not anticipate
touching the core at this time.

Kind regards,

--
Ben Caradoc-Davies <Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com>
Software Engineer
CSIRO Exploration and Mining
26 Dick Perry Avenue, Kensington WA 6151, Australia

-----Original Message-----
From: Adrian Custer [mailto:acuster@anonymised.com]
Sent: Monday, 11 February 2008 4:11 PM
To: Justin Deoliveira
Cc: Caradoc-Davies, Ben (E&M, Kensington);
geoserver-devel@lists.sourceforge.net;
geotools-devel@lists.sourceforge.net
Subject: Re: [Geotools-devel] [Geoserver-devel] svn commit access

Hi Ben,

Justin is correct about procedure but you may be using Rob A. to vet
your work and he may be asking you to commit directly to svn on his
say-so. I believe he nominated you which should satisfy Justin.

You do know that svn and wiki are different accounts, right? The former
goes through admin@anonymised.com dotnet.

Ideally you would be willing to grab the OSGeo copyright assignment
agreement off the wiki and sign your copyright over to OSGeo (for all
the good reasons explained on the page). Oh, and make Rob sign it too,
all to show you are more hip than he these days. All that info is in the
developer guide which you should read to get a sense of what's in there
for when you need it.

For the xicles stuff, the process is ever changing and complex so Jody
seems to be the one who really understands it. I did notice codehaus go
down for a server upgrade this weekend and it's been rock solid for me
since then---let's hope that lasts.

--adrian

On Sun, 2008-02-10 at 22:34 -0500, Justin Deoliveira wrote:

Hi Ben,

Usually how it works to get commit access you need to submit a number

of

patches first. Once your work has gained the trust of one of the

current

committers they can nominate you.

Until then, you should be able to check out the code from svn,

generate

diffs for patches, without having authentication to commit.

Our setup on Xircles is a bit odd at the moment. Currently its an all

or

nothing setup, where if you join the project you are given full blown
commit access. I have been meaning to set this up so that you can join

the project as just a user, but have yet to get around to it.

-Justin

Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com wrote:
> I created my Xircles account two weeks ago and applied to join the
> GeoServer and GeoTools projects, but my credentials are still being
> refused when I try to svn commit. Xircles still lists my application

as

> pending, but my Jira account is alive.
>
> Who are the "project despots" for these, and how long should it take

to

> get commit access?
>
> Who are the svn admins who can diagnose technical problems with

access

> to the repositories?
>

On Mon, 2008-02-11 at 17:07 +0900, Ben.Caradoc-Davies@anonymised.com wrote:

Thanks, Adrian.

Do I need both a TOPP agreement for GeoServer and an OSGeo for GeoTools?

Yes.

I did not know that svn is a separate account. Should I email
admin@anonymised.com dotnet, or wait until my paperwork is processed?

On the Geotools side, we are still working informally so do both
together. Geoserver may block on the paperwork, I don't know their
rules.

I will be indeed working closely with Rob A, mainly on getting community
schemas up and going on the GeoServer 1.6 / GeoTools 2.4 branches. I
will be working in community/unsupported, and I do not anticipate
touching the core at this time.

Kind regards,