[GRASS5] Porting list

Michael Barton wrote:

Radim,

I went through your list, took out the commands that were in the menu and
have the following remainder. I've made a few notes. Could you take a minute
to look and see if you agree? Thanks.

Michael

I don't know all, so I send cc to list.

----- revised list -----

d.ask - for programming
d.colorlist - mostly for programming but can add anyway

I don't think that this should be in menu. Colors should
appear in combo boxes. The option should be defined
with options = D_color_list().

BTW: default values dont work in GUI.

d.info - mostly for programming but will add anyway

I'am not sure that thsi should be in menu, we have enough
modules doing something useful, I think.

g3.region - obsolete (in g.region)

Not yet, and I am not sure if 'Set from a 3d raster map'
should be added to g.region, because of g3d dependency.

g.ask - for programming
g.filename - for programming
g.findfile - for programming
g.parser - for programming
g.tempfile - for programming

Yes.

r.average - obsolete (in r.statistics)

> r.median - obsolete (in r.statistics)
> r.mode - obsolete (in r.statistics)

No idea, but if it is osolete, it should be removed (from CVS).

r.in.arc - add (newly ported? I just forgot?)
r.watershed - add (newly ported?)

Probably.

tcltkgrass - obsolete (replaced by GIS manager)

So it can be removed?

v.in.dwg - not in default compile

Yes, but it could be conditional.

v.kcv - add (newly ported?)
v.mkgrid - add (newly ported?)

Yes.

v.neighbors - add
v.out.dxf - add (recently updated)

Yes.

WHAT ARE THESE??
poly_to_bmif -
bmif_to_cell -

No idea.

Radim

I think there are unresolved issues here - I see that the floating point prohibition in r.statistics seems to be gone, but in a silly test example I just tried testing r.statistics against r.average using a floating point base map, and I get output from r.average, but all NULLs from r.statistics using method=average.

On Nov 15, 2004, at 3:53, Radim Blazek wrote:

r.average - obsolete (in r.statistics)

> r.median - obsolete (in r.statistics)
> r.mode - obsolete (in r.statistics)

No idea, but if it is osolete, it should be removed (from CVS).